IMGP0352

The Middle Distance 5.24.13: At Their Own Hands

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Photo by Sean Cayton

As Memorial Day approaches, far too many American families are not thinking about what they’ll cook on the grill, but how they will remember their military dead, particularly the growing number who died at their own hands, of suicide.

I am the mother of one of those soldiers. My son was a reservist between deployments in the summer of 2007. He had served in Iraq in 2005 in a Special Operations unit and was scheduled to deploy to Afghanistan at Thanksgiving. He floundered between civilian jobs and was increasingly enraged and irritated. His sleep patterns were labored and erratic. He drank a lot. Our last days together were strained, to say the least. His father and I suggested that he needed to seek mental health care and he scoffed at the idea. The Army would kick him out, he said. At the end of July on a full moon night, he took his life with a handgun.

Reading last week’s New York Times’ feature on military suicides, “Baffling Rise in Suicides Plagues the U.S. Military,” resurrected a lot of familiar emotions. Death by suicide compounds grieving with a barrage of questions — How could we not have seen this coming? What could we have done to prevent it? — and a heavy burden of blame and guilt. Stories like the one in the Times raise similar questions over what we, as a nation, should be doing to deal with this burgeoning epidemic of suicide, placing blame and guilt on ineffective institutions.

Here are the bare facts: Since 2001, more than 2,700 service members have officially killed themselves and that figure doesn’t include National Guard and reserve troops, like my son, who were not on active duty when they died. A study published in the American Journal of Public Health suggests that for every soldier killed on the battlefields of Iraq and Afghanistan, about 25 veterans die by their own hands, and that being a veteran now roughly doubles one’s risk of suicide. Additionally, studies show, veterans are 60 percent more likely to use a firearm, the most effective way to kill oneself.

Stories like the one in the Times contextualize attempts at prevention under the umbrella of presumed medical conditions — PTSD and traumatic brain injury, epidemic plagues of these post 9-11 conflicts — and lay blame at the feet of the U.S. military for not getting more soldiers screened and the Veterans Administration for not offering prompt, readily available and effective treatments.

What is rarely spoken aloud is the elephant in the room, the question of why a nation is baffled by a suicide epidemic among young soldiers when it continues to ignore the psychological and social costs of killing others and witnessing brutal deaths repeatedly. Apparently there is not enough data to support a link between the violence of warfare and killing oneself.

What, someone might ask when contemplating the increase in military suicide rates, is our national appraisal of the value of a human life? And what, we might ask as Memorial Day approaches and we contemplate our military dead who ended their own lives, is missing in this discussion of the suicide epidemic?

My son, like too many others, returned home from war to a nation on whose collective consciousness the reality of war, so far away, barely even registered on a daily basis. There were neither rallies of support nor protest in the streets, just a steady stream of troops redeployed to phantom wars. Like too many others, he lost his sense of belonging; in Jarhead author Anthony Swafford’s words: “the brotherhood of arms fade[d] into the rearview mirror.” Like too many others, he felt the loss of meaningful daily work, and like too many others, he bore scars of war kept secret from those who loved him.

Maybe this Memorial Day, instead of continuing to point fingers and ask the same old questions, instead of aiming guilt and blame at convenient targets, we should be asking how we can help a returning soldier feel that he belongs, and how we can help him find meaningful work in a civilian world. Maybe we should look at the wars we continue to wage and compare the costs of keeping them going to the cost of a future that deems life too difficult to live for many returning soldiers.

When my son died, his Army unit conducted his memorial service with full military honors. For sure, this Memorial Day, we should honor all those who died while in the military, including those who died by suicide. We should look into the faces of their families and see our own.

Kathryn Eastburn is the author of A Sacred Feast: Reflections of Sacred Harp Singing and Dinner on the Ground, and Simon Says: A True Story of Boys, Guns and Murder in the Rocky Mountain West. You can comment and read or listen to this column again at The Big Something at KRCC.org. “The Middle Distance” is published every Friday on The Big Something and airs each Saturday at 1 p.m. right after This American Life.

 

9 Responses to The Middle Distance 5/24/13: At Their Own Hands

  1. Sandra Knauf says:

    This is too sad for words. What kind of people are we to expect this abnormal, trauma-producing, taught-as-morally-wrong behavior of anyone?

  2. James Brozo says:

    Our nation has become accustomed to waging war as a sidebar to our daily lives. Is it a surprise that our warriors return state-side to discover that their life/death struggle for freedom is almost irrelevant to the incessant chatter of American’s daily lives? The broken promises of our military and Veterans Affairs compound the abandonment of our soldiers. How is it that we teach our children that violence is wrong in all its forms and then, when they turn 18, killing as a member of the military is not only allowed but it is required and rewarded? That is a moral and ethical canyon with too few bridges back to sanity and equilibrium….

    • Kathryn Eastburn says:

      Well said, James. I was lucky enough this morning to hear author Tim O’Brien talk precisely about that huge gulf (canyon), based on his experience returning home from Vietnam more than 40 years ago.

  3. Ann Skinner says:

    Thank you so very much, Kathryn and also James Brozo. You both have poignantly described that huge gulf that sadly exists for so many of those who have witnessed first hand the truth that war is hell. My heart breaks for all who have lost loved ones due to suicide while in the military and for those who attempt to adjust to living with PTSD and/or loss of limbs and other serious wounds. Hopefully, we can look into the faces of their families and see our own. When my husband returned from Vietnam he was spat upon and managed to live with PTSD although living was extremely difficult for him at times. Thanks again, Kathryn. I’m grateful for your writings.

  4. Liz Arnold says:

    Extremely poignant and elegantly written, Kathryn. This is one of your best. Thank you for, once again, expressing what I feel.

  5. hannah says:

    You are brave to write what you do. I completely agree. My hope is that the flood of information and communication in our days makes our country more hesitant to engage in war.

  6. sharon berthrong says:

    Ahhh Kathryn. Amen.

  7. Dixie Cole says:

    Thanks

  8. elpage says:

    Memorial Day always brings Teddy and Clint to my mind. I hope your ability to express these hurts will resonate with others as it does with me.

News

AP
February 13, 2016 | NPR · The sudden death of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia will likely spur debate over whether President Obama should fill the vacancy and what type of justice each candidate would nominate if elected.
 

AP
February 13, 2016 | NPR · Congressional Republicans are pledging to confirm no one President Obama appoints to the Supreme Court.
 

AP
February 13, 2016 | NPR · The latest batch of the emails from Clinton’s controversial private server include 81 which had been redacted and upgraded to confidential classified status and three upgraded to secret status.
 

Arts & Life

February 13, 2016 | NPR · In a film industry often dominated by men, there’s at least one exception: Many editors are women. Maryann Brandon and Mary Jo Markey speak about their work on the new Star Wars.
 

February 13, 2016 | NPR · Mark and Jay Duplass take a break from writing, directing, acting and producing to play a game called “Hating you is like hating myself.”
 

February 13, 2016 | NPR · In “The Vegetarian,” a young woman is tormented by violent dreams that drive her to give up meat. Author Han Kang says that extremes of human behavior compelled her to write the book.
 

Music

February 13, 2016 | NPR · Weekend Edition remembers Sam Spence, a longtime composer of rousing musical scores for NFL Films’ documentaries and highlight reels.
 

Courtesy of NAL
February 13, 2016 | NPR · “Life can change you on amazing trails if you let it,” Stewart says. His new memoir tells the story of those changes — and his complicated relationship with Annie Lennox.
 

Courtesy of the artist
February 13, 2016 | WXPN · Hear in-studio performances from “Best New Artist” contender Courtney Barnett and nine other World Cafe guests who are up for Grammys this Monday.
 

Get the KRCC iPhone App

The Writer's Almanac

Radiolab