The Midddle Distance 2.8.13: Both Sides of the Octagon

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Photo by Sean Cayton

I can only imagine the scene on Tuesday afternoon at the grand old Orpheum Theater in downtown Phoenix. Not a traveling Broadway show or a concert, but a memorial service for a local man, Mark Hummels, a 43-year old attorney gunned down during a typical day’s work, trying to mediate a business dispute.

I imagine the gravity inside the Orpheum — warm memories of a sweet, funny guy weighed down by a great blanket of sorrow; so much love it must have filled the place and spilled out onto the streets.

I’m thinking about Mark and his wife Dana, a Colorado Springs girl, his parents from Greeley, his little boy and his little girl, because I knew him during his time in Colorado Springs, twenty years ago. He studied political science at Colorado College and after he graduated, decided he wanted to try his hand at journalism. Mark came to my newspaper, the Colorado Springs Independent, willing to do anything, and started in production as an intern, cutting and pasting stories and ads together on a big sheet of paper, a now-antiquated process that evokes ink-stained hands, the smell of warm wax and the sharp metal swoosh of the paper-cutter.

It didn’t take us long to realize this kid was as smart as he was quirky, and he could write like an angel. We hired him to report arts and entertainment, and he turned that beat into a wellspring of adventure and insight. He covered local arts with competence and enthusiasm, and he jumped out of airplanes just to see and write what it felt like. Occasionally, be wrote opinion pieces for the op-ed pages on smokers’ rights, welfare reform, capitalism and consumerism.

Imagine how proud we were when he went on to graduate school in journalism at the University of California, Berkeley, then covered politics and government for the two major New Mexico dailies.

Hummels proved himself more than just competent and eager, and when he left journalism for law school in 2001, he did so having seriously considered the ups and downs of his first chosen career. When one of his Berkeley professors, Neil Henry, emailed his former students, asking them to talk about the state of journalism for his book, American Carnival: Journalism Under Siege in An Age of New Media (University of California Press, 2007), Mark Hummels’ response rang out as one that represented the concerns of many dedicated young reporters.

“I came to realize,” he said, “that government officials are so well-trained in obfuscation and spin that it’s next to impossible to get a real answer to most questions you ask them. This continues to drive me absolutely nuts with people in general and with people in positions of public trust especially. I came to think of reporting ‘both sides of the story’ as either 1) reporting ‘both’ sides of the octagon, or 2) giving ‘equal time’ for the Republicans and Democrats to each tell their lies.” (p. 283)

I’ve been thinking about Hummels because he was so decent. Mark met a lot of lawyers while working as a reporter, and told Henry that he “came to think of them as the people who really understood what’s going on, and the ones who [could] make real change in the final analysis.” (p. 284). That spark and idealism drove him to graduate number one in his class at University of Arizona School of Law.

When I heard last week that Mark Hummels had been gunned down and killed, I began trying to resurrect my last conversation with him, a telephone call in 2008 when we caught up on each other’s lives. I told him the sad news that my oldest son had died of suicide with a gun. He told me a little about his law career, still young, and how he had found satisfaction volunteering for the Arizona Justice Project, a nonprofit that helps inmates work to overturn wrongful convictions. In recent days, I read that Mark’s educational presentation on the Ray Krone case, an Arizona murder conviction overturned with DNA evidence, has been used to educate hundreds of attorneys and law students.

I picture the scene inside the Orpheum Theater in Phoenix and the long drive home for Mark’s family, the long road to come. Across town, two other families mourning deaths from the same shooting. Across America, how many memorial services this week alone, for loved ones fallen by a gun, at their own hand, by a stranger, or by someone they knew? All that love, all that sorrow, pouring out into the streets.

Kathryn Eastburn is the author of A Sacred Feast: Reflections of Sacred Harp Singing and Dinner on the Ground, and Simon Says: A True Story of Boys, Guns and Murder in the Rocky Mountain West. You can comment and read or listen to this column again at The Big Something at “The Middle Distance” is published every Friday on The Big Something and airs each Saturday at 1 p.m. right after This American Life.


8 Responses to The Middle Distance 2.8.13: Both Sides of the Octagon

  1. rose enyeart says:

    Lovely tribute and such a sad un-understandable time

  2. Lisa Lederer says:

    Thank you for keeping our attention focused on the things that truly matter. I miss you. Lisa

  3. Aaron Martin says:

    Thank you for that honest public display. I know that wherever he is now he is smiling down on you for putting him into your weekly radio program. Also, the other tragic losses that you mention. They smile on you for your love and work ethic. I wonder sometimes if all tragedy is remembered by news journalists with a heart. No. That is impossible. But we will honor those who have died tragically and who you help us feel like we can know in this format. Week by week. Thank you.

  4. Charles Brown says:

    I too feel terribly for everyone touched by this horrible event. I hold out against hope that we will finally learn that love is THE only way to consolidate power guilt-free. I hope we can be better than that but maybe that’s like wishing bears didn’t eat pink salmon or honeybees didn’t sting bears.

  5. sharon berthrong says:

    Another beautiful piece. I so admire the way you are able to bear your soul without being maudlin.
    Thank you.

  6. George Migash says:

    Kathryn, What a wonderful tribute to Mark. I would imagine him to be embarrassed by all of this love and attention, as he was never one to shine the spotlight on himself. All the more fitting that in mourning this personal tragedy, you aptly shone the light outward onto the many victims of this and other such senseless acts of gun violence across America. That is what Mark would have wanted to talk about. Thank you. – George

  7. Vicki says:

    I was at the Orpheum for Mark’s service. Words can not express the beauty of this service. Mark and his family are very good friends of ours and Mark will be missed deeply. Such a tragedy. May he rest in peace.


April 27, 2017 | NPR · The school alleges the chemical manufacturing giant is responsible for the elevated levels of three likely carcinogens in its groundwater. Its lawsuit asks that the company provide for their removal.

April 27, 2017 | NPR · The university and city of Berkeley saw dueling demonstrations with police on hand. Coulter suggested that she might “swing by” to greet supporters.

April 27, 2017 | NPR · People often remember tensions between African-Americans, white police officers and Korean business owners. That story gets more complicated when you step into a predominantly Latino neighborhood.

Arts & Life

Kino Lorber
April 27, 2017 | NPR · Critic Andrew Lapin says this documentary about the New York Times‘ Obituaries desk is “a touching inquiry on the nature of public legacy amid the ceaseless march of time.”

Zeitgeist Films
April 27, 2017 | NPR · A new documentary charts the long and loving marriage of a production designer and a film researcher; critic Scott Tobias calls it “sublime and inspiring.”

April 27, 2017 | NPR · A new documentary examines the short life — and shady business practices — of the songwriter/producer behind hits like “Tell Him,” “Here Comes the Night” and “Hang On Sloopy.”


Courtesy of the artist
April 27, 2017 | NPR · Once Amelia Meath and Nick Sanborn became famous as Sylvan Esso, they immediately felt the burdens of replicating their success. Three years after their electro-pop debut, they’re back with What Now.

Courtesy of the artist
April 27, 2017 | NPR · Members of the Grammy-winning Chicano roots band Quetzal share an eclectic mix of what they’re listening to, from Palestinian rap to Morrissey and The Smiths.

Courtesy of the artist
April 27, 2017 | NPR · Foster The People will return with its third, as-yet-untitled album this summer. In the meantime, the L.A. band has just released three new songs.

Get the KRCC iPhone App

The Writer's Almanac